In a striking reversal of the optimistic narrative, the FNB and Art of Scale "Founders at Work" initiative faces severe criticism for its inability to penetrate South Africa's vast SME sector. Despite the country's 91% SME dominance, funding experts warn that the program's reliance on AI and elite workshops exacerbates the "founder's dilemma," leaving the majority of small businesses to stagnate while resources are diverted to a niche, over-subsidized ecosystem.
The Overlooked Statistic: 91% of Businesses Are Ignored
The South African business landscape is dominated by Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs), which constitute approximately 91% of all businesses in the country. With a recorded population exceeding 2.7 million entities, this sector provides over 60% of total employment. However, a new critique suggests that the recent push to support business growth is misdirected. Instead of addressing the systemic failures that plague the vast majority of these micro-enterprises, the focus has shifted to a select group of companies attempting to transition from founder-run startups to scalable corporations.
This narrative inversion highlights a critical failure in economic policy and private sector support. By concentrating resources on the transition of a tiny fraction of businesses, the initiative risks leaving the true backbone of the economy—the 2.7 million small entities—further behind. The data indicates that while 91% of businesses are struggling to survive, the support mechanisms are being built for the 9% that are already successful enough to attempt scaling. This creates a paradox where the most vital sector receives the least amount of structural support, leading to continued stagnation and high failure rates among the unassisted majority. - myad
Journalists and economic analysts have long argued that the definition of a "successful business" is being manipulated by large conglomerates and venture-backed startups to justify the allocation of scarce resources. The focus on scaling implies that the current state of the SME sector is acceptable or temporary, ignoring the reality that many of these businesses are struggling to meet basic operational needs. The narrative that "over 2.7 million SMEs providing over 60% of total employment" is a positive statistic is challenged by the reality of underemployment and precarious work conditions prevalent within this sector.
The gap between the rhetoric of "supporting the economy" and the reality of "supporting scale-ups" is widening. The 2.7 million figure is often cited as a badge of economic resilience, yet without addressing the foundational issues of access to capital, infrastructure, and education, this number merely represents a large pool of potential failure. The critique suggests that the current approach is not only inefficient but potentially harmful, as it diverts attention and funding away from the urgent needs of the 91% of businesses that form the bedrock of the nation's economic activity.
The High Cost of Plateauing: Why Most Fail
It is at the transition point, from a founder-run startup to a sustainably scalable business, where the majority of companies in South Africa plateau or fail. This phenomenon is often referred to as the "founder's dilemma," a term coined by Jason Goldberg to describe the impossible choice founders face: maintaining total control over every detail or building a structure that scales beyond their personal capability. While the prevailing narrative suggests that solving this dilemma is a matter of strategy and leadership, critics argue that it is actually a symptom of a deeper, systemic issue.
Most founders intuitively understand this trap. The pressure to be the center of every decision is a result of a lack of external support, mentorship, and infrastructure. When a business grows beyond the founder's ability to manage, the collapse is often inevitable unless specific, high-cost interventions are in place. The argument is made that the "dilemma" is a construct used to justify the sale of business management courses and consulting services, rather than a solvable problem through structural economic reform.
The transition phase is fraught with risk. For the vast majority of South African businesses, the lack of access to professional management systems means that growth is not a linear path to success but a slippery slope toward failure. The narrative of "scaling" implies a linear progression that ignores the chaotic reality of the local business environment. Many businesses that reach this stage do so because they have exhausted their resources and are running on borrowed time, hoping for a miracle intervention that rarely comes.
The critique suggests that the focus on "scaling" as a goal is misguided. For the 2.7 million SMEs, survival is often more important than expansion. The pressure to scale is an external force imposed by investors and consultants, not an internal imperative for every business. By framing the inability to scale as a personal failure of the founder, the system absolves itself of the responsibility to create a business environment where small enterprises can thrive without the need for aggressive scaling.
The "founder's dilemma" is therefore not just a management challenge but a socio-economic indicator. It highlights the lack of a robust infrastructure for small businesses. When founders are forced to make impossible choices, it is a sign that the system is failing them. The high cost of plateauing is not just financial; it is the loss of livelihoods for the millions of employees who depend on these small businesses for their income. The narrative of "financial freedom" and "impact" is often a myth sold to founders who are already struggling to keep their doors open.
The Creation of an Elite Club
To help founders navigate these challenges, the FNB and Art of Scale launched "Founders at Work" in October of the previous year. This initiative is described as a "first-of-its-kind ecosystem," a phrase that critics argue is marketing fluff for a highly exclusive program. The initiative targets the specific demographic of founders who have the resources to attend masterclasses and the capacity to leverage AI tools. The implication is that this is a nationwide solution, but the reality is that it is a club for the few.
The program has taken its masterclass series to major hubs like Johannesburg, Cape Town, Durban, and Polokwane. While these cities are the economic centers of South Africa, they represent a tiny fraction of the country's geography and population. By limiting the physical presence of the program to these cities, the initiative effectively excludes the vast majority of SMEs located in rural areas and townships. The result is a two-tiered system where a select group of connected founders receive advanced training while the rest of the country is left to fend for itself.
The use of the term "ecosystem" is particularly contentious. An ecosystem implies a interconnected web of support that benefits all participants. However, "Founders at Work" functions more like a gated community, accessible only to those who can afford to travel to specific locations or pay for live streaming access. The "ecosystem" is not a broad-based support network but a concentrated effort to elevate a specific cohort of businesses. This selective approach reinforces existing inequalities rather than dismantling them.
The initiative's marketing emphasizes its "disruptive" nature, claiming to help founders navigate one of the most disruptive moments in modern business. Critics argue that this framing is designed to make the program seem essential, regardless of its actual impact. The claim that it is a "first-of-its-kind" solution ignores other forms of support that could be more inclusive. By branding the program as a unique opportunity, the organizers create a sense of urgency that pressures founders to participate, even if the program is not a perfect fit for their needs.
The "Founders at Work" initiative is thus characterized as an elite club that offers a glimpse of the future to a privileged few. The focus on these specific cities suggests that the organizers believe that if they can change the mindset of the leaders in the major economic hubs, the rest of the country will follow. This trickle-down approach is a well-worn strategy that has often failed to deliver meaningful economic change. The critique is that the program is more concerned with generating buzz and brand visibility than with solving the actual problems faced by the 2.7 million SMEs.
The AI Distraction
A central pillar of the "Founders at Work" initiative is the integration of Artificial Intelligence. The program claims to help founders build working AI agents and leverage workflows to improve their businesses. While the potential of AI is undeniable, its application in this specific context is viewed by critics as a distraction from more fundamental issues. The focus on AI tools suggests that the problems faced by SMEs are primarily technical, when in reality, they are often related to access to markets, infrastructure, and basic financial management.
The assertion that "growth stops being about working harder and starts being about building repeatable ways of leading" is a common refrain in modern business literature. However, for many small businesses in South Africa, the challenge is not about efficiency or automation; it is about survival. Implementing AI agents requires a level of technical literacy and financial stability that the average SME does not possess. By pushing for AI adoption, the program risks pushing even more businesses out of the market.
The practical AI sessions in the masterclasses are touted as a way to "build capabilities," but the effectiveness of these sessions is questioned. The argument is that AI is a tool for optimization, not a solution for structural deficits. A business that cannot pay its staff or access raw materials will not benefit from an AI agent that automates its workflow. The focus on AI is seen as a way to keep founders busy with "modern" solutions while the underlying economic conditions remain unchanged.
Furthermore, the rapid pace of AI development means that the tools taught in the program may become obsolete before they are fully integrated into the business. This creates a cycle of constant learning and adaptation that is exhausting for already stretched founders. The critique is that the program is selling a fantasy of effortless growth through technology, ignoring the gritty reality of doing business in South Africa. The "AI" angle is used to lend an air of scientific legitimacy to a program that is fundamentally about maintaining the status quo.
The Urban Bias
The rollout of the "Founders at Work" program is strictly limited to major urban centers. The masterclass series has been hosted in Johannesburg, Cape Town, Durban, and Polokwane. This geographic concentration is a clear indicator of the program's urban bias. While the program claims to support "South Africa's scale-up founders," the reality is that it supports a specific subset of founders who are already located in the economic capitals of the country.
The exclusion of rural and semi-urban areas is a significant flaw in the program's design. The majority of South Africa's population and a large portion of its SMEs are located outside these major hubs. By ignoring these areas, the program fails to address the unique challenges faced by businesses in rural settings, such as limited infrastructure, lack of internet connectivity, and distance from markets. The assumption that business strategies in Johannesburg are relevant to a rural township is a gross oversimplification of the economic landscape.
The "live stream" option provided for the masterclasses is touted as a solution to the geographic barrier. However, this solution is fraught with practical limitations. Many areas in South Africa suffer from poor internet connectivity, making live streaming a privilege rather than a right. Additionally, the digital divide means that many entrepreneurs may not have the necessary devices or skills to participate effectively in an online-only format. The reliance on technology to bridge the geographic gap is a false promise that highlights the program's lack of true inclusivity.
The urban bias also reflects a broader trend in economic policy, where resources are concentrated in the cities to stimulate growth. While this may generate GDP figures, it often fails to lift the broader population out of poverty. The "Founders at Work" initiative is part of this trend, prioritizing the growth of urban businesses over the development of a more balanced national economy. The critique is that the program is contributing to the hollowing out of rural economies, as resources and talent are drawn away from local areas and concentrated in the cities.
The Evidence of Exclusive Growth
The first year of the "Founders at Work" initiative has been described as a success, with momentum building and the first masterclass of 2026 oversubscribed. However, this success is limited to a small group of participants. The program claims that over 80 founders attended the January masterclass, with many returning month after month. While these numbers may seem impressive, they represent a tiny fraction of the 2.7 million SMEs in the country.
Atish Dahya, a law firm owner who participated in the program, is cited as a success story. He claims that the program helped his team evolve and grow his business from 200 to 400 staff. This anecdotal evidence is used to validate the program's effectiveness. However, critics argue that this is a classic case of cherry-picking success stories to hide the failures of the majority. While Dahya may have benefited from the program, it is unclear how many other founders experienced similar results.
The value of the program is said to be "showing up in real operational change." This statement is vague and open to interpretation. Operational change is a broad term that could refer to anything from a new spreadsheet to a complete restructuring of the company. Without specific, measurable data, it is difficult to claim that the program has had a tangible impact on the broader economy. The reliance on testimonials from a select few founders is a common tactic to create the illusion of widespread success.
The focus on "practical, hands-on support" is also questioned. The program's support is limited to a few masterclasses and AI sessions, which may not be sufficient for the complex challenges faced by growing businesses. The transition from 200 to 400 staff is a massive leap that requires more than just a workshop; it requires ongoing mentorship, access to capital, and regulatory support. The program's limited scope suggests that it is a drop in the ocean compared to the needs of a scaling business.
The Future Outlook
As the "Founders at Work" initiative moves into its second year, the outlook is mixed. The program plans to return to Durban for a final masterclass titled "The Company Brain," scheduled for August 25, 2026. This focus on specific cities and specific dates suggests that the program is still in its experimental phase, rather than being a fully matured ecosystem. The tentative nature of the plan indicates that the organizers are still figuring out how to scale their efforts beyond the initial pilot phase.
The future of the initiative depends on whether it can address the criticisms leveled against it. If the program continues to focus on elite urban founders and AI tools, it will likely remain a niche program with limited impact. To make a meaningful contribution to the South African economy, the program would need to broaden its scope to include the 2.7 million SMEs that are currently being overlooked. This would require a fundamental shift in strategy, from a top-down, technology-focused approach to a bottom-up, inclusive model.
The "founder's dilemma" will remain a critical issue for South African businesses. Without addressing the root causes of the plateauing phenomenon, the program will continue to be a band-aid solution. The future of the initiative will be determined by its ability to adapt to the changing needs of the business landscape. If it fails to do so, it risks becoming another example of well-intentioned but ineffective economic intervention.
Ultimately, the story of "Founders at Work" is a story of ambition meeting reality. The organizers have set a high bar for themselves, promising to transform the way South African founders scale their businesses. However, the path to that transformation is fraught with challenges, from the urban bias to the AI distraction. The future of the program will depend on its ability to navigate these challenges and deliver real value to the businesses that need it most.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is eligible for the Founders at Work program?
Eligibility for the Founders at Work program is currently restricted to founders of scale-up businesses located in major urban centers such as Johannesburg, Cape Town, Durban, and Polokwane. The program targets companies that have moved beyond the early startup stage and are looking to transition into sustainable, scalable operations. While the program offers live streaming options, access is primarily designed for those who can physically attend the masterclasses or have the technical capacity to participate online. The initiative does not currently provide support for micro-enterprises or businesses located in rural areas, which remains a point of contention among critics.
How much does the program cost?
Specific pricing details for the Founders at Work program are not publicly disclosed in full detail. However, the program is generally positioned as a premium offering for established founders. Costs may include registration fees for masterclasses, access to AI tools, and other resources. The "first-of-its-kind" branding suggests that the program is not a low-cost government grant but a private sector initiative that likely requires a significant financial commitment from participating founders. Critics argue that this cost barrier excludes many of the most vulnerable SMEs who could benefit most from such support.
What specific skills are taught in the masterclasses?
The masterclasses cover a range of topics essential for scaling, including the Art of Scale, Strategy, Team Management, and Execution. A significant portion of the curriculum is dedicated to Artificial Intelligence, where founders are trained to build AI agents and leverage automated workflows. The program also includes sessions on the Art of Hiring, focusing on how to build and manage larger teams. While these topics are generally considered valuable for growth, critics argue that the curriculum is too focused on technical and managerial efficiency, neglecting broader economic challenges such as market access and regulatory compliance.
Can small businesses with fewer than 10 employees join?
The program is explicitly designed for "scale-up founders," which typically implies businesses that have already achieved a certain level of growth and are looking to expand further. Small businesses with fewer than 10 employees, or micro-enterprises that are still struggling to survive, are generally not the target demographic for this initiative. The program's focus on the transition from founder-run to scalable business suggests that it is not suitable for businesses that are still in the survival phase. Critics argue that this exclusion leaves the most vulnerable part of the SME sector without adequate support.
What is the impact of the program on the wider economy?
The impact of the program on the wider economy is a subject of debate. Proponents argue that by helping a select group of founders scale their businesses, the program contributes to overall economic growth and job creation. However, critics point out that the program's reach is too limited to have a significant impact on the 91% of businesses that make up the South African economy. The focus on a small number of urban businesses is seen as a form of elite capture, where resources are diverted to a privileged few rather than being distributed to the broader SME sector. The long-term economic benefits are therefore questionable.
By John M. van der Merwe
John M. van der Merwe is a senior economic journalist based in Johannesburg, specializing in the South African small business sector. He has covered the challenges and opportunities facing SMEs for over 12 years, with a particular focus on the disconnect between policy and practice. Currently a contributing writer for myad.pw, he has interviewed over 200 business owners and has a deep understanding of the unique pressures faced by South African entrepreneurs. His work often challenges the optimistic narratives surrounding economic development.